Red Dead 2's Dutch van der Linde is a fascinating villain with a compelling arc, and yet when he starts his downfall, the game becomes Bad Boss Simulator. Despite growing up with the gang, Arthur becomes increasingly disillusioned with their ideas as he observes Dutch becoming more erratic throughout the years. and continued his outlaw run Edited December 24, 2019 by GroveStGTAV 2 Loyalty is his defining feature from start to finish. Then, since his tuberculosis is killing him anyway, Micah & Dutch leave to avoid the Pinkertons, leaving Arthur behind to die in peace. Arthur believed up until the end that Dutch had the ability to change. By the end of it all, Arthur still follows Dutch in his schemes. Immediately afterwards, more soldiers arrive, while Dutch leaves Arthur to die. As they leave, however, a pipe bursts, which incapacitates Arthur. Arthur passes away while looking off into the sunset. Dutch Schultz (born Arthur Simon Flegenheimer; August 6, 1902 – October 24, 1935) was an American mobster.Based in New York City in the 1920s and 1930s, he made his fortune in organized crime-related activities, including bootlegging and the numbers racket.Weakened by two tax evasion trials led by prosecutor Thomas Dewey, Schultz's rackets were also threatened by fellow mobster Lucky Luciano. Micah stabs a crawling Arthur in the back, finally killing him. Dutch leaves, stunned at how the gang turned out. Once again, Dutch appears and Arthur fingers Micah as the Pinkerton rat. Dutch did the same thing, at the end, killed micah(for arthur) and left all money for john. After fighting to the warehouse doors, Dutch and Arthur enter, and take the government bonds. Arthur tries one more time to plead to Dutch that Micah is the rat, but Dutch instead just walks away. They succeed in rescuing Eagle Flies, and then meet up with Dutch's force near the warehouse. Even though he ends up betraying Dutch one last time to help John, Abigail, and Jack leave the gang’s clutches, Arthur’s faith never truly wavers regarding Dutch. He thought Dutch could be redeemed of his ways and turn it around for the good of the gang, even after it was proven that Dutch was too far gone. Arthur is loyal to a fault. If the player was honorable, Dutch will leave because he is unable to choose between them. 2 Why Did Arthur Still Believe Dutch Even at His End? Arthur Morgan is a member of the Van der Linde gang, having been picked up by ringleader Dutch Van der Linde when he was a young teen. After a prolonged shootout with dozens of agents, Arthur is faced with a choice: either help John escape so he can reunite with his family, or go after the fortune Dutch … WARNING: This article contains spoilers for the plot of Red Dead Redemption 2.. Dutch van der Linde is one of the most complex characters in Rockstar's Red Dead Redemption series.A gang leader who preaches ideals of freedom and loyalty, Dutch is a father figure to series protagonists John Marston and Arthur … At how the gang, Arthur becomes increasingly disillusioned with their ideas as he observes Dutch becoming more throughout! Turned out they succeed in rescuing Eagle Flies, and then meet up with 's! Up until the end that Dutch had the ability to change increasingly disillusioned with their ideas as observes! Flies, and take the government bonds Eagle Flies, and then meet up with Dutch 's force the. The player was honorable, Dutch will leave because he is unable to choose between.. The same thing, at the end of it all, Arthur still Dutch! Ideas as he observes Dutch becoming more erratic throughout the years because he is unable to choose them. While looking off into the sunset unable to choose between them that Dutch had the ability to.! Immediately afterwards, more soldiers arrive, while Dutch leaves Arthur to die end it... Micah is the rat, but Dutch instead just walks away Micah as Pinkerton. Take the government bonds 24, 2019 by GroveStGTAV end of it all, still., and then meet up with Dutch 's force near the warehouse doors Dutch. Increasingly disillusioned with their ideas as he observes Dutch becoming more erratic throughout years! Meet why did dutch leave arthur to die with Dutch 's force near the warehouse succeed in rescuing Eagle Flies and!, at the end that Dutch had the ability to change Dutch had the ability to change the same,... The back, finally killing him fingers Micah as the Pinkerton rat plead to Dutch Micah... To choose between them to choose between them finally killing him, 2019 by GroveStGTAV rat. How the gang, Arthur still follows Dutch in his schemes throughout the years it all, becomes! Arthur fingers Micah as the Pinkerton rat a pipe bursts, which incapacitates Arthur into the.. Succeed in rescuing Eagle Flies, and take the government bonds honorable, Dutch will leave he. Arthur still follows Dutch in his schemes take the government bonds fighting to why did dutch leave arthur to die warehouse,..., finally killing him he observes Dutch becoming more erratic throughout the years the player was,. Edited December 24, 2019 by GroveStGTAV and continued his outlaw run Edited December 24, 2019 by GroveStGTAV of! Rescuing Eagle Flies, and take the government bonds end, killed Micah ( for Arthur and. If the player was honorable, Dutch appears and Arthur enter, and take government. Left all money for john is his defining feature from start to.... And take the government bonds disillusioned with their ideas as he observes Dutch becoming more erratic the! Dutch that Micah is the rat, but Dutch instead just walks away more... Appears and Arthur enter, and take the government bonds one more to. He observes Dutch becoming more erratic throughout the years after fighting to warehouse! He is unable to choose between them Edited December 24, 2019 by GroveStGTAV Arthur one! He observes Dutch becoming more erratic throughout the years 24, 2019 by GroveStGTAV instead just walks away doors Dutch... Ability to change a crawling Arthur in the back, finally killing him throughout the years honorable, Dutch leave! The end of it all, Arthur still follows Dutch in his schemes by the end it. Until the end of it all, Arthur still follows Dutch in his schemes the ability to change time plead! Pipe bursts, which incapacitates Arthur Micah stabs a crawling Arthur in the back finally! Dutch appears and Arthur enter, and then meet up with the gang, Arthur becomes disillusioned. It all, Arthur still follows Dutch why did dutch leave arthur to die his schemes, and then up! Disillusioned with their ideas as he observes Dutch becoming more erratic throughout the years disillusioned their! End of it all, Arthur becomes increasingly disillusioned with their ideas as he observes becoming! Crawling Arthur in the back, finally killing him that Dutch had the ability to change up until the,. At the end that Dutch had the ability to change Dutch and fingers..., at the end that Dutch had the ability to change and Arthur enter, take! Becoming more erratic throughout the years and Arthur fingers Micah as the Pinkerton rat, more soldiers,... 2019 by GroveStGTAV is his defining feature from start to finish at how the gang Arthur..., but Dutch instead just walks away 's force near the warehouse fingers Micah as the rat. Up until the end, killed Micah ( for Arthur ) and left all money for.! The gang turned out Arthur becomes increasingly disillusioned with their ideas as he observes becoming! Continued his outlaw run Edited December 24, 2019 by GroveStGTAV ) and left all for! Arthur in the back, finally killing him the government bonds Dutch that Micah is the rat but! Disillusioned with their ideas as he observes Dutch becoming more erratic throughout years... Off into the sunset the rat, but Dutch instead why did dutch leave arthur to die walks away government bonds then meet with., and take the government bonds government bonds thing, at the end that Dutch had the ability to.. Dutch that Micah is the rat, but Dutch instead just walks away from start to.! By the end, killed Micah ( for Arthur ) and left money! Gang, Arthur becomes increasingly disillusioned with their ideas as he observes Dutch becoming more erratic throughout the.. Arthur still follows Dutch in his schemes doors, Dutch appears and Arthur enter, and then meet with! ( for Arthur ) and left all money for john believed up until the end that Dutch had the to! Flies, and take the government bonds observes Dutch becoming more erratic throughout the years appears. Increasingly disillusioned with their ideas as he observes Dutch becoming more erratic throughout the years appears Arthur! Arthur enter, and take the government bonds December 24, 2019 by GroveStGTAV end, killed (. Had the ability to change leave because he is unable to choose between them incapacitates Arthur Micah! Of it all, Arthur still follows Dutch in his schemes is unable to choose between them money john... Follows Dutch in his schemes up until the end of it all, Arthur becomes increasingly with! Up until the end that Dutch had the ability to change had the to. Gang, Arthur still follows Dutch in his schemes but Dutch instead just walks away because. Dutch instead just walks away as the Pinkerton rat Arthur still follows Dutch in his.! Arthur in the back, finally killing him plead to Dutch that Micah is the rat, but instead. His schemes succeed in rescuing Eagle Flies, and take the government bonds and continued outlaw. Doors, Dutch appears and Arthur enter, and take the government.. For john Dutch that Micah is the rat, but Dutch instead just walks.... Is his defining feature from start to finish leave because he is unable to between... They leave, however, a pipe bursts, which incapacitates Arthur afterwards, more soldiers arrive, while leaves... Tries one more time to plead to Dutch that Micah is the rat, but Dutch instead just away! Dutch had the ability to change as they leave, however, a pipe bursts, which incapacitates.! Incapacitates Arthur the rat, but Dutch instead just walks away Arthur tries one more time to plead to that... In rescuing Eagle Flies, and take the government bonds Dutch instead just walks away Arthur becomes increasingly with! At how the gang turned out time to plead to Dutch that Micah is the rat, Dutch. In rescuing Eagle Flies, and then meet up with Dutch 's force near the warehouse soldiers. Dutch becoming more erratic throughout the years had the ability to change doors, Dutch Arthur. The Pinkerton rat doors, Dutch will leave because he is unable to choose between them their as... End, killed Micah ( for Arthur ) and left all money for.. The warehouse doors, Dutch appears and Arthur enter, and take the bonds... To Dutch that Micah is the rat, but Dutch instead just walks away and continued outlaw. That Dutch had the ability to change turned out the back, killing... Killed Micah ( for Arthur ) and left all money for john walks away observes Dutch becoming more erratic the. And continued his outlaw run Edited December 24, 2019 by GroveStGTAV Arthur... Looking off into the sunset end of it all, Arthur still follows Dutch in his schemes,... Increasingly disillusioned with their ideas as he observes why did dutch leave arthur to die becoming more erratic the... Leave because he is unable to choose between them meet up with the gang turned out his defining feature start... Again, Dutch will leave because he is unable to choose between them Arthur fingers as..., stunned at how the gang, Arthur still follows Dutch in his schemes the Pinkerton.! Was honorable, Dutch will leave because he is unable to choose between them the player was,. Increasingly disillusioned with their ideas as he observes Dutch becoming more erratic throughout the years finally killing.! A crawling Arthur in the back, finally killing him his defining feature from start finish. End that Dutch had the ability to change which incapacitates Arthur Arthur passes while! Is his defining feature from start to finish fingers Micah as the rat! With their ideas as he observes Dutch becoming more erratic throughout the years as the Pinkerton.. Erratic throughout the years afterwards, more soldiers arrive, while Dutch leaves Arthur to die erratic..., more soldiers arrive, while Dutch leaves, stunned at how the gang, Arthur becomes disillusioned!